Templates & Checklists

Managing Your Property: Exploring the Advantages and Disadvantages of Property Management

As a property owner, one of the most crucial decisions you'll have to make is whether to self-manage your property or hire a property manager. While self-managing offers greater control over your property, it can also be time-consuming and require specialized knowledge. On the other hand, hiring a property manager can offer professional expertise and save you time, but it also comes at a cost. In this blog post, we'll explore the pros and cons of each option to help you decide which is best for you.


What is a Property Manager?

A property manager is a professional hired by property owners to oversee the daily operations of their rental properties. They act as the point of contact between tenants and owners and handle various responsibilities to ensure the smooth running of the property.

Here are some of the tasks a property manager might handle:

Advertising and Marketing: One of the essential tasks of a property manager is to advertise and market the property to attract potential tenants. They may create and manage listings on online rental platforms, create ads for local newspapers and classifieds, and use other creative methods to promote the property. Effective advertising and marketing strategies can help ensure that the property is seen by as many potential tenants as possible, leading to higher occupancy rates.

Tenant Screening: Tenant screening is an important responsibility of a property manager to ensure that they select the most qualified tenants for the property. The screening process typically includes conducting background and credit checks, verifying employment and income, checking references, and verifying identity. Proper screening can help prevent issues like non-payment of rent or damage to the property by irresponsible tenants.

Negotiating Lease Agreements and Renewals: Property managers are responsible for negotiating lease agreements with potential tenants and renewals with current tenants. They typically review lease agreements to ensure that they comply with local, state, and federal laws, and negotiate terms that are beneficial to both parties. Effective negotiation skills can help ensure that the lease agreement protects the owner's interests while being fair to the tenant.

Collecting Rent and Security Deposits: Property managers are responsible for collecting rent and security deposits from tenants. They ensure that tenants pay their rent on time and handle any issues related to late payments or non-payment of rent. They also handle security deposits and ensure that they are held in compliance with local, state, and federal laws and returned to tenants in a timely manner.

Handling Maintenance Requests and Coordinating Repairs: Property managers are responsible for handling maintenance requests and coordinating repairs for the property. They ensure that repairs are completed promptly and that they are of high quality. They may also handle preventative maintenance, such as regular inspections of the property to identify any issues before they become major problems.

Conducting Regular Property Inspections: Property managers conduct regular inspections of the property to ensure that it is in good condition and to identify any potential issues. They may inspect common areas, appliances, and other features of the property to ensure that they are functioning correctly and address any issues promptly.

Handling Tenant Disputes and Evictions: Property managers handle tenant disputes and evictions, if necessary. They mediate disputes between tenants and handle the legal process of eviction if it becomes necessary. Proper handling of tenant disputes and evictions can help prevent legal issues and ensure that the property runs smoothly.

Ensuring Compliance with Local, State, and Federal Laws and Regulations: Property managers are responsible for ensuring that the property is in compliance with local, state, and federal laws and regulations. They stay up-to-date with any changes in the law and ensure that the property complies with requirements related to health and safety, fair housing, and other legal issues. Proper compliance can help prevent legal issues and ensure that the property is safe and habitable for tenants.

Pros of Hiring a Property Manager

There are many benefits to hiring a property manager or property management company to oversee your rental property. A property manager can provide valuable expertise and services to help owners maximize their profits and minimize their stress. From tenant screening to maintenance and repairs, property managers can handle a variety of tasks and responsibilities that can be time-consuming and challenging for owners to manage on their own. Additionally, property managers can provide peace of mind by handling any issues that may arise with tenants, ensuring that the property is well-maintained, and maximizing the property's potential for long-term profitability. In this section, we will explore some of the key benefits of hiring a property manager or property management company.

Expertise and Experience: Property managers have the expertise and experience to handle the various tasks related to managing a property. They have a deep understanding of local rental market conditions and laws, and can use their knowledge to help owners make informed decisions about their properties. Additionally, property managers have the experience to handle any issues that may arise with tenants, contractors, or vendors.

Reduced Owner Responsibilities: Hiring a property manager can significantly reduce the owner's responsibilities related to managing the property. Property managers handle tasks such as advertising, tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance, and evictions, freeing up the owner's time to focus on other things. This can be especially beneficial for owners who have multiple properties or who live far away from the property.

Better Tenant Quality: Property managers are responsible for screening tenants and selecting the most qualified candidates. They conduct thorough background and credit checks, verify employment and income, check references, and ensure that tenants meet all other requirements. This can help ensure that the property is occupied by responsible, reliable tenants who are more likely to pay rent on time, take care of the property, and renew their leases.

Higher Occupancy Rates: Property managers are responsible for advertising and marketing the property to attract potential tenants. They use effective strategies to reach a wide audience and help ensure that the property is occupied by tenants as much as possible. Additionally, they handle tenant retention strategies, such as renewals and incentives, which can help keep occupancy rates high.

Professional Management: Hiring a property manager can give owners peace of mind knowing that their property is being professionally managed. Property managers have the expertise and experience to handle any issues that may arise, from maintenance and repairs to tenant disputes and evictions. This can help prevent legal issues and ensure that the property is well-maintained and profitable.

Access to Property Management Tools: Property managers often have access to advanced property management tools and software, which can help them streamline their operations and provide better service to owners and tenants. These tools can help with tasks such as rent collection, maintenance requests, and communication with tenants, making the management process more efficient and effective.

Cons of Hiring a Property Manager

While there are many benefits to hiring a property manager or property management company, there are also some potential drawbacks that owners should consider. For example, the cost of hiring a property manager can be significant and may cut into profits. Additionally, owners may have less control over their property and may need to rely on the property manager to make decisions and handle issues. There may also be communication issues or conflicts that arise between the owner and the property manager, which can lead to tension and dissatisfaction. In this section, we will explore some of the potential drawbacks of hiring a property manager or property management company, as well as some strategies for mitigating these issues.

Cost: One of the main drawbacks of hiring a property manager is the cost. Property managers typically charge a percentage of the monthly rent or a flat fee, which can significantly impact the owner's profits. In addition to the management fee, owners may also be responsible for additional expenses, such as advertising costs, maintenance and repair costs, and legal fees. For owners who are looking to maximize their profits, the cost of hiring a property manager may be prohibitive.

Less Control: When an owner hires a property manager, they are essentially turning over control of their property to someone else. While property managers have the expertise and experience to manage the property, owners may feel like they are not in control of the day-to-day operations. Additionally, some property managers may make decisions that the owner disagrees with, which can lead to conflict and tension.

Communication: Communication can be a challenge when working with a property manager. Owners may not always be kept in the loop about important decisions or events related to their property, which can be frustrating. Additionally, some property managers may not be very responsive to owner inquiries or may not communicate clearly or effectively, which can lead to misunderstandings and problems.

Lack of Personal Touch: Property managers may not provide the same level of personal touch as an owner who self-manages their property. Owners who self-manage their property often develop personal relationships with their tenants and take a more hands-on approach to managing their property. Property managers, on the other hand, may not have the time or inclination to develop these kinds of relationships, which can impact the tenant experience.

Potential for Incompetent or Unethical Managers: Unfortunately, not all property managers are created equal. There is a risk of hiring an incompetent or unethical property manager who may not have the experience or expertise needed to manage the property effectively. Additionally, some property managers may engage in unethical behavior, such as embezzlement or fraud, which can be financially devastating for the owner. Owners should carefully research and vet potential property managers to mitigate this risk.

Considerations When Hiring a Property Manager

Experience and Expertise: One of the most important factors to consider when hiring a property manager is their experience and expertise. Owners should look for property managers who have a proven track record of success managing similar properties in the local area. Additionally, owners should consider the property manager's level of expertise in areas such as rental market conditions, tenant screening, property maintenance and repairs, and legal issues related to rental properties.

Communication and Responsiveness: Communication and responsiveness are key factors to consider when hiring a property manager. Owners should look for property managers who are easy to communicate with and respond promptly to owner inquiries and tenant requests. Additionally, owners should consider how the property manager communicates important information and how they keep owners informed about the status of their property.

Property Management Agreement: Before hiring a property manager, owners should carefully review the property management agreement. The agreement should clearly outline the services provided, the management fee, and the responsibilities of both the owner and the property manager. Additionally, owners should carefully review any termination clauses in the agreement, in case they are not satisfied with the property manager's services.

References and Reviews: Owners should carefully research potential property managers and ask for references from other property owners who have worked with the manager. Additionally, owners should read online reviews and ratings to get a sense of the property manager's reputation and level of service. This can help owners make an informed decision about whether a particular property manager is a good fit for their needs.

Management Fees

When hiring a property manager, one of the most significant costs for owners is the management fee. Property management fees can vary depending on a variety of factors, including the location and type of property, the level of services provided, and the property manager's experience and reputation.

In general, property management fees can range from around 4% to 10% of the monthly rent, with some property managers charging a flat fee instead. For example, if an owner is renting out their property for $2,000 per month and the property manager charges a 7% management fee, the owner would pay $140 per month in management fees.

It's essential for owners to carefully consider the management fee and whether it represents a good value for the services provided. A lower management fee may be attractive, but it's important to ensure that the property manager is still providing high-quality services and expertise. Conversely, a higher management fee may be justified if the property manager has a proven track record of success and can help the owner maximize their profits.

In addition to the management fee, owners should also consider other potential expenses associated with hiring a property manager. For example, the property manager may charge additional fees for services such as advertising, tenant screening, and maintenance and repairs. Additionally, owners should consider the cost of any legal fees associated with drafting the property management agreement and resolving any disputes that may arise.

How Property Management Software Comes in if You Decide to Self-Manage

If you decide to self-manage your property, property management software can help you streamline tasks and stay organized. These tools can help you handle tasks like tenant screening, rent collection, and maintenance requests. They can also provide detailed reports and analytics to help you track the financial performance of your property.

While using software can save you time and money compared to hiring a property manager, it does require some initial investment in terms of time and money to set up and learn how to use effectively.

Conclusion

Deciding whether to hire a property manager or self-manage your property can be a challenging decision. It's important to carefully consider the pros and cons of each option and evaluate your own needs and capabilities. Whether you decide to hire a property manager or self-manage, be sure to do your research, set clear expectations, and stay organized. With the right approach, you can ensure that your property is well-maintained and profitable.

Hello and welcome!

My name is Nick Caucci and I help run the Rentroom blog. Over the years, I have seen and helped many different property managers and owner-operators streamline their daily, weekly, monthly, and yearly workflows.

This page may contain affiliate links.

Related Articles

The Significance of Security Deposits: Understanding Deductions and Protecting Landlords' Interests

Learn about the permissible deductions landlords can make from these deposits and understand the distinction between damage and wear and tear. We also delve into the legal recourse available to tenants if their security deposit is not returned. Whether you're a landlord seeking financial protection or a tenant wanting to safeguard your rights, this comprehensive guide provides valuable insights to ensure a fair and transparent rental experience.
Legal

Managing Your Property: Exploring the Advantages and Disadvantages of Property Management

Learn about the pros and cons of hiring a property manager for your rental property. Discover the benefits of expert guidance and stress-free property management, as well as potential drawbacks and considerations to keep in mind.
Templates & Checklists

How to Seamlessly Transition to a New Property Management Software

This blog post explores the benefits of switching to a modern property management system and offers tips for a smooth transition. We discuss why old tracking methods like pencil and paper, Excel spreadsheets, and QuickBooks are no longer suitable for modern property management. We highlight three reasons to consider a new system, compare QuickBooks to dedicated property management software, list ten features to look for in a system, and provide five transition tips. By following our advice, you can streamline your operations, save time and money, and improve your property management.
Templates & Checklists

How to Write a Tenant Welcome Letter (Sample Included)

The post provides a comprehensive guide on what should be included in the letter, including details on move-in dates, utility reminders, renters insurance requirements, maintenance procedures, parking information, neighborhood guidelines, property condition, laundry and trash collection information, and other property rules. The guide also offers a sample tenant welcome letter that can be downloaded and used as a template. Overall, a tenant welcome letter is an important step in establishing clear communication and setting expectations for a successful tenancy.
Templates & Checklists

Free Non-renewal of Lease Letter Template

We have provided a comprehensive guide to help educate landlords on the process of non-renewing a lease agreement. We have explained what a lease non-renewal letter is and when it needs to be sent. We have also provided information on state laws regarding non-renewal notices and a sample letter for landlords to use as a reference. Additionally, we have covered common reasons for non-renewal and what can happen once the letter is sent, including holdovers and steps that can occur after the tenant vacates the property. Lastly, we have covered tenant rights when it comes to deciding not to renew a lease agreement. By following the guidelines outlined in this post, landlords can ensure a smooth and legally compliant non-renewal process.
Templates & Checklists

Free Security Deposit Return Letter Template

A security deposit refund letter is a crucial document that must be provided to tenants by landlords to ensure a smooth and successful security deposit return process. This blog post covers the importance of a security deposit refund letter, how to write one, what to include in it, how to send it to tenants, what not to do, and the legal consequences of failing to return a security deposit. Additionally, we discussed situations where landlords can withhold some or all of the deposit and alternatives to providing a security deposit refund letter. By following these guidelines, landlords can fulfill their legal obligations and maintain positive relationships with their tenants.
Templates & Checklists

What is a Past Due Rent Notice | Free Past Due Rent Notice for Tenants

Learn the importance of past due rent notices for landlords. We defined what a past due or late rent notice is and provided guidance on when and how to send one. We also covered best practices for drafting and sending the notice, including what information to include, how to maintain a professional tone, and how to keep a record of delivery. Additionally, we highlighted the potential consequences of not sending a notice and explained the legal procedures landlords should follow if payment is not received.
Templates & Checklists

Navigating Rent Collection: The Pros and Cons of Accepting Partial Payments in 2023

This post discusses the pros and cons of accepting partial payments from tenants who are struggling to pay rent. It also compares the alternative approach of offering payment plans and discusses how property management software like Rentroom can help landlords manage their rental properties and payment collection processes. Ultimately, the decision to accept partial payments or offer payment plans will depend on the individual circumstances of the landlord and the tenant, and landlords should carefully consider the potential benefits and drawbacks of each approach. Property management software like Rentroom can provide added control and customization to the rent collection process through features like the ability to toggle partial payments on and off.
Legal

Using PayPal Or Venmo To Collect Rent? Think Again!

Payment apps like Venmo or PayPal may not be the best option for landlords with multiple properties or many tenants. These apps have transaction limits and lack advanced features, making property management software, like Rentroom, a more suitable choice for managing multiple properties and tenants. Property management software provides features like automation, scalability, and reporting capabilities to help manage a large number of properties and tenants. It's important for landlords and tenants to keep accurate records and understand the tax implications of using Venmo or PayPal for rent payments.
Templates & Checklists

Pros and Cons: Cash Payments for your Rental Properties?

As a landlord, there are both pros and cons to accepting cash payments from tenants. On the one hand, cash payments provide a level of anonymity and privacy, and for some tenants, paying in cash may be more convenient or traditional. On the other hand, accepting cash payments can be challenging for landlords, particularly when it comes to tracking payments and ensuring compliance with legal and tax requirements.
Legal

10 Steps for Writing an Effective Rental Listing to Find New Tenants

Find your next tenants with ease by following our expert tips on writing effective rental listings. Learn how to showcase your property's best features and reach a wider audience with our step-by-step guide.
Templates & Checklists

Free Pet Addendum for Residential Lease Agreements

This post covers the topic of pets in rental properties and why it is important for landlords to have a pet addendum in place. The post explains what a pet addendum is, when landlords need one, the pros and cons of allowing pets in the building, and the process of writing a pet addendum. The post also covers the pet deposit, the legal requirements surrounding emotional support animals, and the potential consequences of not covering all types of pets in a lease agreement. The post concludes by emphasizing the importance of having a clear understanding of the laws and guidelines surrounding pets in rental properties and the benefits of having a comprehensive pet addendum in place.
Templates & Checklists

How to Find New Tenants for Your Rentals on Craigslist

Filling vacancies can be a challenging task for property managers and landlords. One of the most effective ways to attract potential renters is by posting listings on websites like Craigslist. In this guide, we will walk you through the process of creating a compelling listing, selecting the right location, using high-quality photos, promoting your listing, managing response times, and previewing your listing. By following these steps, you can increase your chances of filling vacancies and attract new tenants.
Templates & Checklists

Can Tenants Change The Locks Without Landlord Permission?

This post provides information on the laws and best practices for changing locks in a rental property. Tenants generally have the right to change their locks with the landlord's permission, but laws vary by state and municipality. Reasons for changing locks include feeling unsafe, wanting more privacy, and improving security. Smart locks can provide added convenience and security, but may come with limitations and potential issues. Landlords should consider the costs and benefits of changing locks and weigh them against potential legal liability.
Legal

Arkansas Eviction Laws: Process & Guide for Landlords in 2023

Massachusetts eviction laws are complicated. They require you to follow specific processes before you’re able to evict a tenant. Failure to follow those processes could lead to unwanted tenants remaining in your property. Worse yet, certain actions you take could provide the tenant with a perfect defense against eviction. They may even lead to fines, penalties, and jail time, especially if you try to take the eviction into your own hands. The message is simple: You need to know the law before you attempt to evict a tenant.
Eviction Laws

How To Write A Rent Increase Notice: Free Template for Landlords in 2023

Learn how to effectively communicate a rent increase to your tenants with this detailed guide. Discover the best way to notify tenants, reasons for a possible rent increase, limits, and a template for writing a rent increase letter. Ensure compliance with local laws and maintain a positive landlord-tenant relationship with this helpful guide.
Templates & Checklists

What is a Rent Ledger and Why Keeping A Record Of Rent Payments Is Important

A rent ledger is an essential tool for landlords and property managers to keep track of rent payments made by tenants. It is a detailed record of all rent payments, including the date the rent was paid, the amount paid, the payment method, and any late fees or additional charges. Rent ledgers can be physical or digital, and they can be used as evidence in case of an eviction or a legal dispute. Rentroom is a property management software that provides a rent ledger report feature, which allows landlords to easily keep track of rent payments, filter the report by tenant, property, or date range and export the report to a CSV file. By keeping accurate records of rent payments, landlords and property managers can ensure that all rent payments have been made on time and in full and can have a clear record of the financial transactions between the landlord and tenant.
Templates & Checklists

The 13 Best Rental Property Management Software Providers of 2024

Are you in the market for property management software but not sure where to start? Look no further! Our latest blog post compares 13 top providers, detailing their pros, cons, and pricing. Don't miss out on the valuable insights and information we've gathered to help you find the perfect fit for your business needs.
Product Comparisons

How To Write A Lease Addendum

A comprehensive understanding of what a lease addendum is, why it is often needed, how to add one to a lease and the different types of lease addendums. It also highlights the importance of compliance with lease addendum laws, which vary by state and local jurisdiction and it provides an example of a lease addendum. Additionally, it includes information on how to write an addendum to a lease, ensuring that it is consistent with the original lease agreement and does not contradict any existing terms. This information can be useful for landlords, tenants, and legal professionals when dealing with lease addendums.
Templates & Checklists

How to Create a Flawless Rental Resume

It is good practice for tenants and landlords to work off of rental resumes because it provides a clear and concise way to present and review important information about the tenant. For tenants, a rental resume can help to increase their chances of being accepted as a tenant by demonstrating their responsibility and reliability as a tenant. It also allows them to present their rental history, employment history, and financial information in an organized manner. For landlords and property managers, a rental resume provides a quick and easy way to review the tenant's qualifications and determine if they are a reliable tenant. It helps them to understand the tenant's employment stability, rental history, and financial situation, which can help to minimize the risk of rent defaults and evictions.
Templates & Checklists

How To Write A Landlord Rental Recommendation Letter For A Tenant

As a landlord, one of your most important responsibilities is to find and select tenants who will take care of your property and pay rent on time. A rental reference letter can help you make an informed decision when deciding to rent your property to prospective tenants. This process is remarkably easy and can provide landlords and property managers with a level of comfort that they are renting to someone with a positive track record. This is why as an industry, it is helpful to require reference letter and also provide letters for former tenants.
Templates & Checklists

Delaware Eviction Laws: Process & Guide for Landlords in 2022

Landlords can turn their properties into a steady source of passive income by renting them out. But if you try to do that without knowing the different eviction laws in Delaware, you could run into trouble when you need to evict a tenant from one of your properties.In Delaware, following the proper eviction procedures is essential.Inadequately following the necessary steps provides the tenant with a defense that they can utilize to justify extending their tenure in your property. These counterarguments may, in certain circumstances, be powerful enough to render void the complaint that you file against the tenant. You can make certain that the necessary procedures are followed and that you have a valid case for eviction if you collaborate with a professional attorney throughout the course of the eviction process. In addition, having the tenant consult with an attorney during the drafting process of the lease agreement helps ensure that the tenant is aware of their rights as well as the possible consequences that may result from a violation of the agreement.
Eviction Laws

Rentroom vs. TenantCloud: Property Management Software Comparison

Making the right choice is imperative when selecting a property management software tool. At Rentroom, we understand that once you choose a software partner, get onboarded, and invite your tenants...chances are you and your business will stick with the product you select for an extended period. In this post we examine TenantCloud vs. Rentroom.
Product Comparisons

Rentroom vs. Rentredi: Property Management Software Comparison

Making the right choice is imperative when selecting a property management software tool. At Rentroom, we understand that once you choose a software partner, get onboarded, and invite your tenants...chances are you and your business will stick with the product you select for an extended period. In this post we examine RentRedi vs. Rentroom.
Product Comparisons

Rentroom vs. Doorloop: Property Management Software Comparison

Making the right choice is imperative when selecting a property management software tool. At Rentroom, we understand that once you choose a software partner, get onboarded, and invite your tenants...chances are you and your business will stick with the product you select for an extended period. In this post we examine Doorloop vs. Rentroom.
Product Comparisons

30-Day Notice to Vacate: Free Template for Landlords in 2022

A 30-day notice to vacate is a legal document that a landlord sends to a tenant who they wish to evict. Alternative terms include eviction notice or lease termination letter. As the name implies, the document gives the tenant 30 days’ notice of their eviction, which gives them enough time to make new living arrangements or contest the reason for eviction stated in the letter.
Templates & Checklists

Rental Inspection Checklist: Free Templates for Landlords 2023

Landlords should use these reports before welcoming tenants, after tenants leave, and during tenancies. They’re vital for identifying potential issues. Rental inspection reports also give you the opportunity to ask your tenants about any problems they’re experiencing.
Templates & Checklists

Massachusetts Eviction Laws: Process & Guide for Landlords in 2023

Massachusetts eviction laws are complicated. They require you to follow specific processes before you’re able to evict a tenant. Failure to follow those processes could lead to unwanted tenants remaining in your property. Worse yet, certain actions you take could provide the tenant with a perfect defense against eviction. They may even lead to fines, penalties, and jail time, especially if you try to take the eviction into your own hands. The message is simple: You need to know the law before you attempt to evict a tenant.
Eviction Laws

Important Rental Property Tax Deductions in 2023

Rental property investors have access to a number of key tax write-offs. Make sure your business is taking advantage of these.
Real Estate Taxes

Rentroom Case Study: Ambassador Apartments

Ambassador Apartments is a manager of student housing assets in Upstate New York carting to SUNY Genesio students. Ambassador currently manages over 240 beds. Steve and his team have been using Rentroom for over a year.
Case Study
View All Blog Articles